Call Best Bully Sticks (877) 483-5853

Want Coupons & Sale Updates?

Privacy Policy

Peanut Butter Dog Treats by The Cookie Rookie

scout PB cookies



Happy New Year’s from Best Bully Sticks! Many of you probably made cookies this holiday season and maybe consumed more than you planned! But let’s face it, those cookies weren’t fit for Fido.

The recipe we’re featuring today, however, is:

Peanut Butter Dog Treats by The Cookie Rookie.

This vegetarian treat can be made hypoallegenic, too. If your dog is allergic to wheat, you can substitute other flours.





PB cookie rookie



2½ cups whole wheat, rice, or coconut flour (the latter 2 may have a slightly different consistency)

1 teaspoon baking powder

1 cup natural peanut butter

1 cup water

2 tablespoons honey

1 egg

For instructions on how to make these fun and easy dog treats (and many cute photos of a yellow lab named Scout), visit The Cookie Rookie’s Peanut Butter Dog Treats!


Many thanks to Becky at The Cookie Rookie for sharing her dog treat recipe with us!

Bone Appetit!

Here are some more Drool Dog Recipes to bake up this winter:


Doggie Pupcakes for someone special’s Birthday or Gotcha Day!

Mighty Dog Mutt Balls from the Canine Chef Cookbook

Fresh Apple Dog Treats


Weekly Drool Recipe: Apple Peanut Butter Dog Treat


The old “Apple a Day” mantra could be just as true for you pup as you! Apples are a great source of natural fiber, cancer-fighting nutrients and not to mention Vitamins A & C! Reward your pup with a crunchy, healthy treat with these easy and cute Apple Peanut Butter Dog Treats from Aimee at Irresistible Pets! Follow her simple recipe below!

Ripe Green or Red Apple(s)
Peanut Butter

Small Apple Shaped Cookie Cutter
Potato Peeler

Time Required
10 minutes



Learn how to make this Apple Peanut Butter Dog Treat at Irresistible Pets!

Since apples can go bad pretty quickly once cut, we suggest giving your pet a couple (based on their size) and enjoy the rest or share with family!

Bone Appétit & Enjoy!


A big thank you to Aimee and her pup Chuy for sharing their great recipe and photos with us! Check out their adventures at Irresistible Pets!

Weekly Drool Recipe: Pumpkin & Peanut Butter Braaaaain Pupcakes

HAPPY HOWL-O-WEEN! It’s no trick! It’s all treats around here at BBS! is excited to celebrate this October 31st with a scrumptiously scary dog treat! Erica at For the Love of Pooch blog shared her Pumpkin & Peanut Butter Brain Pupcake recipe with us and we’re sharing it with you! This fall-flavored, Halloween-themed treat will have your dog’s tail wagging! Have a ghoulishly great October 31st, Bully Fans!

1 C. of whole wheat flour (regular or white)
1 egg
2 tbsp olive oil
1 tbsp. honey
1/2 C. skim milk
1/4 C. unsweetened & unsalted peanut butter
1/8 C. pumpkin (not pumpkin pie filling)
1/4 C. water

1/4 C. pumpkin
1 oz low fat cream cheese

1. Preheat oven 350 degrees.

2. Mix flour, egg, olive oil, honey, skim milk, peanut butter, pumpkin, and water together. Batter should be thick.

3. Pour into cupcake tins about 2/3 full.

4. Bake for 20 – 25 minutes. Let cool.

5. Mix 1/4 C. of pumpkin with 1 oz of cream cheese. Refrigerate for 30 minutes.

6. Using a Wilton #12 tip, pipe the left and right hemispheres of the brain then pipe the middle.

Recipe Notes: Cut into small pieces for your dog to avoid choking. Feed this treat sparingly as a very special treat. The honey and cream cheese gives this treat a higher sugar and fat content.

Store in an airtight container for 5 days.

Write date on plastic bag to keep track of expiration date.

Thanks to Erica (& her dog Mochi) for sharing this yummy Halloween treat!

Bone Appétit! And Happy Howl-O-Ween, Bully Fans!

%d bloggers like this: